EN

Monitoring goal progress meta analysis: 0.40 explained.

The monitoring goal progress meta analysis by Harkin, Webb and colleagues found a pooled effect of 0.40 on reaching goals. That effect is real but modest. Also, the authors report monitoring worked better when results were reported or made public, and physically recorded.

What 138 experiments actually measured.

In 2016, Benjamin Harkin, Thomas Webb and six colleagues published in Psychological Bulletin. They pooled 138 studies and 19,951 people. Importantly, they used only experiments, where one group monitored and another did not. Surveys would only describe the kind of person who monitors things. The pooled effect was 0.40, with a confidence interval from 0.32 to 0.48, under a random effects model.

Why the monitoring goal progress meta analysis is only a nudge.

So does tracking your goals help? Yes, but an effect of 0.40 nudges you rather than transforms you. It sits clearly above zero and shows up reliably across many studies. In a room of people chasing goals, a few more get there. Not most of them. Therefore, anyone selling monitoring as the answer is selling 0.40 and calling it 4.

Some details stayed out of reach, including heterogeneity, publication bias and which goals were studied.

Reported, made public, physically recorded.

The paper's own summary says monitoring worked better when people reported results or made them public. It also worked better when progress was physically recorded. How much better, and how public was defined, the author could not see. However, the two failed trials were both private. So the lesson is to record progress publicly instead of keeping it in your head.

Apply the monitoring goal progress meta analysis tonight.

Write your next business number on paper instead of only noticing it in your head.

Name one person who could ask you a hard question about that number out loud.

Questions about monitoring goal progress meta analysis.

What did the monitoring goal progress meta analysis find?

Across 138 experiments and 19,951 people, monitoring had a pooled effect of 0.40 on goal attainment.

Is an effect of 0.40 large?

No. It is real and reliable, but it nudges a few more people towards a goal rather than transforming anyone.

When did monitoring work better in that paper?

The authors report it worked better when results were reported or made public, and physically recorded.

Read the whole chapter.

This lesson covers one section of chapter 11, “Fourteen days”. The book goes further, with the full evidence, the stories and every exercise.

Monitoring goal progress meta analysis: cover of I Want to Start a Business but I Never Actually Start by Diego Segura