Survival Rate of Acquired Businesses: The Real Gap.
The survival rate of acquired businesses is higher than for new startups, but only modestly. French government data from 2012 to 2021 showed three-year survival of eighty-five and a half per cent for transferred businesses. However, newly created ones survived at eighty-one point four per cent, a gap of about four points.
The famous comparison that was never a comparison.
You will often read that ninety per cent of startups fail while eighty per cent of acquired businesses last five years. However, those figures come from different datasets measuring different populations. Nobody compared them directly. So any claim about startup failure rate vs acquisition built on them is a sentence, not a finding. The chapter was nearly built on that number before it got checked.
What the survival rate of acquired businesses really shows.
The French government measured both groups across 2012 to 2021, using three-year survival. Transferred businesses survived at eighty-five and a half per cent, while new ones reached eighty-one point four. So do bought businesses last longer? Yes, but by four points, not ninety against twenty. Also, academic work on two large French datasets finds the gap narrows over time.
Part of the advantage belongs to the buyer.
That academic work also finds the gap partly disappears once founders and firms are accounted for. In short, some of the advantage is not the buying, it is the buyers. People with capital and experience tend to buy, and they were likely to do better anyway. Therefore, buying gets you a slightly better base rate and a different risk. Instead of risking that nobody wants it, you risk that you cannot run it.
Check the survival rate of acquired businesses against your own plan.
Write eighty-five and a half and eighty-one point four on your page, then note the four-point gap in your own words.
Write one line on which risk worries you more: nobody wanting your product, or you failing to run a business.
From the book.
You will read constantly that ninety per cent of startups fail while eighty per cent of acquired businesses survive five years. Those two figures come from different datasets, measuring different populations, and nobody ever compared them with each other, so put them side by side and what you have is a sentence rather than a finding.
I Want to Start a Business but I Can't Quit My Job, chapter 11: Buy the business instead of building it
Questions about survival rate of acquired businesses.
What is the survival rate of acquired businesses in the French data?
Businesses sold or transferred survived three years at eighty-five and a half per cent. Newly created ones survived at eighty-one point four per cent.
Is the ninety versus eighty per cent claim reliable?
No, because the two figures come from different datasets and populations. Nobody ever compared them with each other.
Does buying remove risk?
No, it changes the shape of risk. You stop risking that nobody wants the thing and start risking that you cannot run it.
Read the whole chapter.
This lesson covers one section of chapter 11, “Buy the business instead of building it”. The book goes further, with the full evidence, the stories and every exercise.
Lessons in this chapter.
- 01 How Much Does a Small Business Cost: Real Numbers.
- 02 Survival Rate of Acquired Businesses: The Real Gap.
- 03 Baby Boomer Business Owners Retiring: Where to Look.
- 04 Build vs Buy Decision: The Reflex You Never Priced.
- 05 SBA Loan to Buy a Business: How Deals Get Paid.
- 06 What Is a Search Fund: And What It Cannot Tell You.
- 07 How to Evaluate a Business for Sale in One Hour.
- 08 Can I Afford to Buy a Business: Honest Objections.